By Sara Shipley Hiles, Kaiser Well being Information
WASHINGTON, Mo. — In August, native officers on this small metropolis an hour west of St. Louis voted in opposition to requiring residents to put on masks to stop the unfold of the coronavirus.
On Nov. 23, with COVID circumstances surging and the native hospital overflowing, the Metropolis Council introduced a masks order again for an additional vote. As protesters marched exterior, Councilman Nick Obermark, an electrician, was the only member of the nonpartisan council to change his vote, inflicting the mandate to cross.
One in every of his many causes? He has a baby the identical age as Washington Center College scholar Peyton Baumgarth, 13, who on Halloween grew to become the youngest individual in Missouri to die of COVID issues.
“That hit fairly arduous,” Obermark mentioned later. Although the councilman would not like carrying a masks, he mentioned it is price it if we are able to hold one or two individuals from getting COVID-19.
Washington grew to become the most recent group to flip its stance on masks and different restrictions whereas the coronavirus ravages the nation.
As America enters a darkish winter with out nationwide directives to curb the pandemic, quite a few cities, counties and states should resolve: enact extra restrictions now or go away individuals to their very own will? Some on this tightknit metropolis of 14,000 have found that the reply — and the important thing to altering hearts and minds — lies in how shut and actual the hazard appears.
After a spate of nursing house fatalities early on in Franklin County, the place Washington is situated, two months this summer time handed with out a dying from COVID. Some residents noticed the virus as a big-city drawback and rejected preventive measures.
Households attended weddings with tons of of visitors. Downtown retailers held “Thirsty Thursday,” with members mingling over drinks. At the same time as officers on the metropolis’s hospital urged COVID restrictions, 356 individuals signed a letter to the native paper vowing their opposition to being “compelled to cowl our mouths in public.”
Republican Missouri Gov. Mike Parson has declined to enact a statewide masks mandate. Franklin County Presiding County Commissioner Tim Brinker posted on Twitter July 29: “Franklin County MO. No mandates, low case counts, low to no hospitalizations. Logic! Hold palms clear, and if you do not have the area, cowl your face. We love Freedom and respect human life. Come to Franklin County and lift your kids in God’s Nation! #COVID.”
Embracing freedom and custom is as anticipated right here as following deer looking season or attending the Washington City & Nation Truthful. The town’s downtown, inside view of the swirling brown Missouri River, is lined with historic red-brick buildings and quaint retailers. The Missouri Meerschaum Co. nonetheless produces corn cob pipes on Entrance Avenue. Its motto: “Over 150 Years & Nonetheless Smokin’.”
Within the months earlier than the election, yards sprouted indicators for President Donald Trump, who has downplayed the specter of COVID-19 for the reason that begin of the pandemic.
However the virus crept nearer in September when 74-year-old Ralph Struckhoff died of the illness. The Missourian newspaper printed a story describing him as a wholesome man who had simply achieved a day of development work at his church earlier than he fell unwell. “Please put on a masks in reminiscence of Ralph,” his widow, Jayne Struckhoff, wrote in a letter to the editor. “If this virus can take Ralph, it will possibly take down anybody.”
Some locals started asking: What would it not take for this city to alter? College of Missouri well being communication assistant professor Yerina Ranjit mentioned many elements affect well being choices. As an example, she mentioned, individuals normally observe well being recommendation in the event that they imagine an sickness is severe and that they’re prone to it.
“That is true with COVID as effectively,” she mentioned. Older persons are extra prone to put on masks and social distance. However others may not put on masks in the event that they suppose the virus would not make them very unwell.
Symbolic threats, or issues that individuals really feel threaten their values, may have an effect on habits. In a survey of U.S. adults but to be printed, Ranjit and her colleagues studied media viewing and located that the type of info persons are uncovered to makes an actual distinction. No matter political affiliation, they discovered, Fox Information viewers had been extra prone to suppose the pandemic threatens the American lifestyle, which made them much less prone to put on masks. They had been “shopping for into the concept masks are in opposition to our identification,” she mentioned. Then again, individuals watching MSNBC felt extra afraid of the virus, which brought on them to put on masks.
However in November, Mayor Sandy Lucy seen that attitudes had been evolving. That is when residents heard about Peyton, the center schooler, who declined quickly and died days after being admitted to the hospital, his mom advised KMOV. In line with his obituary, he was identified for his love of Pokémon Go, flag soccer and the St. Louis Blues. “He beloved his puppies Yadi and Louie who be misplaced with out their buddy,” it mentioned. “He beloved listening to music and singing within the faculty choir.”
“Out of the blue there was a dying of a 13-year-old,” Lucy mentioned, “and also you suppose, perhaps this virus is extra vicious than I give it credit score for being.”
Peyton’s mom, Stephanie Franek, pleaded in a TV interview: “Put on a masks if you’re in public, wash your palms and know that COVID is actual.”
In the meantime, circumstances skyrocketed. Between the primary and second masks votes, the overall COVID depend in Franklin County, with a inhabitants round 104,000, climbed from 728 to 4,594, and deaths rose from 19 to 75. Within the week ending Nov. 23, 25% of COVID exams returned constructive outcomes.
Mercy Hospital Washington was working out of area. Hospital President Eric Eoloff tied rising hospitalizations and deaths to the absence of security measures. “As a hospital administrator, I knew we’d be on the receiving finish of the alternatives to not put on the masks and never social distancing,” he mentioned.
In a shock transfer Nov. 19, the Franklin County Board of Commissioners enacted a obligatory masks order. Presiding Commissioner Brinker advised The Missourian that he had spoken to native docs and the St. Louis regional pandemic job pressure, and the numbers “communicate for themselves.” Brinker didn’t reply to requests for remark for this story.
Though the order already utilized to town, the Washington Metropolis Council went additional and permitted its personal masks rule 4 days later. In contrast to the county order, which expires Dec. 20, the metropolis’s mandate will keep in pressure based mostly on metrics associated to the brand new COVID case fee, hospital admissions and deaths.
Dozens of protesters wielded flags and indicators in opposition to obligatory masking exterior Metropolis Corridor the night of the vote. Ali and Duncan Whittington got here with their 4-year-old daughter. “I am right here as a result of I really feel my freedom is being violated,” Ali Whittington mentioned.
Councilman Obermark later mentioned that he had misplaced a number of sleep over his choice. “It wasn’t one factor,” he mentioned. “It was a number of issues that made me change my thoughts.”
The excessive positivity fee, the shortage of capability on the hospital. Figuring out wholesome individuals whom COVID “knocked down” for days. His spouse having to quarantine. And Peyton’s dying.
He mentioned he is aware of masks aren’t a cure-all, however they might assist scale back the unfold till vaccines arrive.
“We tried nothing and it is not working,” he mentioned, “so we have now to strive one thing.”
Subscribe to KHN’s free Morning Briefing.
KHN (Kaiser Well being Information) is a nonprofit information service protecting well being points. It’s an editorially unbiased program of KFF (Kaiser Household Basis), which isn’t affiliated with Kaiser Permanente.