Liz Szabo, Kaiser Well being Information
As an emergency doctor, Dr. Eugenia South was within the first group of individuals to obtain a covid vaccine. She obtained her second dose final week — even earlier than President-elect Joe Biden.
But South stated she’s in no rush to throw away her face masks.
“I actually do not assume I will ever go and not using a masks at work once more,” stated South, college director of the City Well being Lab on the College of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. “I do not assume I will ever really feel secure doing that.”
And though covid vaccines are extremely efficient, South plans to proceed carrying her masks outdoors the hospital as effectively.
Well being consultants say there are good causes to comply with her instance.
“Masks and social distancing might want to proceed into the foreseeable future — till we now have some stage of herd immunity,” stated Dr. Preeti Malani, chief well being officer on the College of Michigan. “Masks and distancing are right here to remain.”
Malani and different well being consultants defined 5 causes Individuals ought to maintain on to their masks:
1. No vaccine is 100% efficient.
Massive scientific trials discovered that two doses of the Moderna and Pfizer-BioNTech vaccines prevented 95% of diseases brought on by the coronavirus. Whereas these outcomes are spectacular, 1 in 20 persons are left unprotected, stated Dr. Tom Frieden, a former director of the Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention.
Malani notes that vaccines have been examined in managed scientific trials at prime medical facilities, below optimum situations.
In the actual world, vaccines are normally barely much less efficient. Scientists use particular phrases to explain the phenomenon. They confer with the safety provided by vaccines in scientific trials as “efficacy,” whereas the precise immunity seen in a vaccinated inhabitants is “effectiveness.”
The effectiveness of covid vaccines might be affected by the way in which they’re dealt with, Malani stated. The genetic materials utilized in mRNA vaccines — made with messenger RNA from the coronavirus — is so fragile that it must be rigorously saved and transported.
Any variation from the CDC’s strict steerage might affect how effectively vaccines work, Malani stated.
2. Vaccines don’t present fast safety.
No vaccine is efficient straight away, Malani stated. It takes about two weeks for the immune system to make the antibodies that block viral infections.
Covid vaccines will take a little bit longer than different inoculations, such because the flu shot, as a result of each the Moderna and Pfizer merchandise require two doses. The Pfizer photographs are given three weeks aside; the Moderna photographs, 4 weeks aside.
In different phrases, full safety will not arrive till 5 or 6 weeks after the primary shot. So, an individual vaccinated on New 12 months’s Day will not be totally protected till Valentine’s Day.
3. Covid vaccines could not stop you from spreading the virus.
Vaccines can present two ranges of safety. The measles vaccine prevents viruses from inflicting an infection, so vaccinated folks do not unfold the an infection or develop signs.
Most different vaccines — together with flu photographs — stop folks from turning into sick however not from turning into contaminated or passing the virus to others, stated Dr. Paul Offit, who advises the Nationwide Institutes of Well being and Meals and Drug Administration on covid vaccines.
Whereas covid vaccines clearly stop sickness, researchers want extra time to determine whether or not they stop transmission, too, stated Phoenix-based epidemiologist Saskia Popescu, an assistant professor within the biodefense program at George Mason College’s Schar College of Coverage and Authorities.
“We do not but know if the vaccine protects in opposition to an infection, or solely in opposition to sickness,” stated Frieden, now CEO of Resolve to Save Lives, a worldwide public well being initiative. “In different phrases, a vaccinated particular person would possibly nonetheless be capable to unfold the virus, even when they do not really feel sick.”
Till researchers can reply that query, Frieden stated, carrying masks is the most secure method for vaccinated folks to guard these round them.
4. Masks shield folks with compromised immune programs.
Individuals with most cancers are at specific threat from covid. Research present they’re extra seemingly than others to develop into contaminated and die from the virus, however will not be protected by vaccines, stated Dr. Gary Lyman, a professor at Fred Hutchinson Most cancers Analysis Middle.
Most cancers sufferers are susceptible in a number of methods. Individuals with lung most cancers are much less capable of battle off pneumonia, whereas these present process chemotherapy or radiation therapy have weakened immune programs. Leukemia and lymphoma assault immune cells immediately, which makes it more durable for sufferers to battle off the virus.
Docs do not know a lot about how folks with most cancers will reply to vaccines, as a result of they have been excluded from randomized trials, Lyman stated. Solely a handful of examine individuals have been identified with most cancers after enrolling. Amongst these folks, covid vaccines protected solely 76%.
Though the vaccines seem secure, “prior research with different vaccines increase considerations that immunosuppressed sufferers, together with most cancers sufferers, could not mount as nice an immune response as wholesome sufferers,” Lyman stated. “For now, we must always assume that sufferers with most cancers could not expertise the 95% efficacy.”
Some folks aren’t capable of be vaccinated.
Whereas most individuals with allergic reactions can obtain covid vaccines safely, the CDC advises those that have had extreme allergic reactions to vaccine substances, together with polyethylene glycol, to keep away from vaccination. The company additionally warns individuals who have had harmful allergic reactions to a primary vaccine dose to skip the second.
Lyman encourages folks to proceed carrying masks to guard these with most cancers and others who will not be totally protected.
5. Masks shield in opposition to any pressure of the coronavirus, regardless of genetic mutations.
To date, research counsel vaccines will nonetheless work in opposition to these new strains.
One factor is evident: Public well being measures — similar to avoiding crowds, bodily distancing and masks — scale back the chance of contracting all strains of the coronavirus, in addition to different respiratory illnesses, Frieden stated. For instance, the variety of flu instances worldwide has been dramatically decrease since nations started asking residents to remain residence and put on masks.
“Masks will stay efficient,” Malani stated. “However cautious and constant use shall be important.”
The very best hope for ending the pandemic is not to decide on between masks, bodily distancing and vaccines, Offit stated, however to mix them. “The three approaches work finest as a staff,” he stated.
Kaiser Well being Information (KHN) is a nationwide well being coverage information service. It’s an editorially unbiased program of the Henry J. Kaiser Household Basis which isn’t affiliated with Kaiser Permanente.
USE OUR CONTENT
This story might be republished totally free (particulars).
Subscribe to KHN’s free Morning Briefing.
KHN (Kaiser Well being Information) is a nonprofit information service masking well being points. It’s an editorially unbiased program of KFF (Kaiser Household Basis), which isn’t affiliated with Kaiser Permanente.